emlarson.com


Home

Blog

Work

Tech

Life

Lord

Play

 Blog: The absolute latest random thoughts


Kari Byron news

previous posts:

Why I'm glad I sold my Apple stock...

Plastic: Good, evil, or something in-between?

How can we help Donald Hurd?

Cool Cat Teacher Blog

Check off your news!

Sounds like...

Mythbusters vs. Newton's Apple

Comment triggers a marital crisis

Shiny, happy Kari Byron

Cognitive Labs: Anomalous Image on Google Maps




earlier posts:

09.2002   10.2002   11.2002   12.2002   01.2003   02.2003   03.2003   04.2003   05.2003   06.2003   07.2003   08.2003   09.2003   10.2003   11.2003   12.2003   01.2004   02.2004   03.2004   04.2004   05.2004   06.2004   07.2004   08.2004   09.2004   10.2004   11.2004   12.2004   01.2005   02.2005   03.2005   04.2005   05.2005   06.2005   07.2005   08.2005   09.2005   10.2005   11.2005   12.2005   01.2006   02.2006   03.2006   04.2006   05.2006   06.2006   07.2006   08.2006   09.2006   10.2006   11.2006   12.2006   04.2007   05.2007   06.2007   07.2007   08.2007   12.2007   01.2008   02.2008   05.2008   06.2008   07.2008   08.2008   12.2008   01.2009   02.2009   03.2009   04.2009   05.2009   06.2009   07.2009   09.2009   10.2009   11.2009   12.2009   01.2010   02.2010   03.2010   04.2010   05.2010   06.2010   07.2010   08.2010   09.2010   10.2010   11.2010   12.2010   01.2011   02.2011   03.2011   04.2011   05.2011   06.2011   07.2011   09.2011   10.2011   11.2011   12.2011   01.2012   02.2012   04.2012   07.2012   10.2012   11.2012   01.2013   02.2013   03.2013   05.2013   05.2014   06.2014   07.2014   12.2014   01.2015   02.2015   03.2015   06.2015   11.2015   02.2016   03.2016   04.2016   05.2016   06.2016   11.2016   04.2017   10.2017  


8.03.2007

Where to turn for "breaking news"?

Sadly, it takes a local tragedy to drive me back to blogging... but I'm carrying on a conversation over Twitter right now and 140 characters just ain't cutting it.

Full disclosure: Dad taught Journalism for 32 years so I have that running in my veins, still know lots of folks in the field. But I'm much more "techie geek" and "social media proponent" than I am "journalist" at heart, so I think the family/personal background makes me balanced rather than biased.

That having been said... I'm having a good-natured debate with folks over... well, what Jon Gordon described on Twitter as "bloggers' etc. response to 35W bridge collapse for Future Tense".

So, first of all, to clarify, "blog" does not equal "citizen journalism". I'm thinking of "blog" as the delivery medium and "citizen journalism" as the source.

And given that... I think that "citizen journalism" is useful and good for breaking news situations like this one... but I also think that blogs are a lousy medium for delivering that jounalism.

In other words, we really need to broker breaking news through the "main stream media".

Now that the news is no longer "breaking", we'll see more use of social tools to point people to interesting stories, supplementary information, etc...

But when a bridge falls down in Minneapolis, I'm not going to fire up Chuck Olsen's blog to find out what happened. It's time for WCCO, KSTP, KMSP or KARE -- all of which had choppers in the air and reporters on the ground within a few minutes. Those choppers showed me the scene, and the reporters on the ground "got the story" from people who were actually there.

Could blogs provide a "personal connection" to the situation? Yes... but only for the people you already know. I hopped on Twitter, told everyone that I of course was all right because I'm almost never near that bridge. Was glad to see that Garrick was alive and well and Tweeting, sure. But that's not where the "news" was at.

Here's an example of my "social media" experience with this particular news. I figured that someone would have cell phone or security camera footage of the collapse. So I popped on YouTube and did a search. Someone claimed to have just what I was looking for. What was it? Archival footage of the Tacoma Narrows bridge collapse from 1940. Because you can't block files on YouTube as SPAM (just comments, as far as I can tell), there was no way to warn away the rest of the planet from the bogus and inappropriate content other than rating it with just one out of five stars.


So, relying on the wide open world of social sites to provide your news is very unwise. Main stream media makes its mistakes (lots of them), but at least they don't intentionally polute the stream with garbage.

Now that the dust has settled (literally and figuratively), I think some of the best conversation about the related issues will be in blogs... but two nights ago, that's not where you wanted to be if you needed to know what the real story was.

Thoughts?

1 Comments:

At August 3, 2007 at 10:01 PM, Blogger Chuck Olsen said...

I somewhat agree -- live television was really the place to see what happened. I put up a YouTube video of KSTP's live footage, mainly for the benefit of nonlocals or those without immediate TV access to see what was going on.

But sites like MNspeak, Mpls Metroblogging, and the Minnesota Monitor became the best places to *aggregate* breaking information -- both mainstream media info and amazing firsthand account like Noah Kunin.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home





 


emlarson.com:   Home | Blog | Work | Tech | Life | Lord | Play | Mail

Entire site contents Copyright © 2000-2005 Eric M. Larson

All rights reserved, please don't steal my stuff, etc. etc. etc.